Video quality comparission » Egypt » Forum about travel in Ukraine
Forum about travel in Ukraine

Forum about travel in Ukraine



ПоискПоиск   Users   Registration   Entrance
Today: 14.03.2025 - 08:09:29
Pages:  1  

Video quality comparission

Advertising


AuthorMessage

Syko

user




Statistics:
Messages: 598
Registration: 09.02.2002

I recently think out a method for numerical estimation of video quality comparing to source material. I have the source SOURCE.avs (or SOURCE.avi, it is not very important) I encode it to DEST1.AVI, DEST2.AVI, DEST3.AVI with different codecs or different codec settings, it is unimportant. The I write some .avs scripts like this: cmp1.avs subtract(avisource("SOURCE.avs"),avisource("DEST1.avi")) cmp2.avs subtract(avisource("SOURCE.avs"),avisource("DEST2.avi")) cmp3.avs subtract(avisource("SOURCE.avs"),avisource("DEST3.avi")) (Also there can be added somithing like SelectRangeEvery(140,14) to reduce processing time) Then I make first pass (with high bitrate and quantizer=2 for DivX) for each of this avs scripts. (Nandub, XviD or DivX5, it is unimportant too, I think) At last I compare estimated file sizes. Most noise - largest size, less noise - lesser size). What do you think about such comparision ?

---------------------
Message # 1 18.03.23 - 10:46:20
RE: Video quality comparission

Jasonb1971

user




Statistics:
Messages: 233
Registration: 11.21.2003

What does the subtract command exactly do?

---------------------
Message # 2 18.03.23 - 10:55:35
RE: Video quality comparission

Spencer

user




Statistics:
Messages: 4,819
Registration: 03.01.2001

interesting 

---------------------
Message # 3 18.03.23 - 11:03:01
RE: Video quality comparission

erikras

user




Statistics:
Messages: 206
Registration: 09.05.2003

so does this actually correlate to quality?

---------------------
Erik R. '89 325i - SOLD April '06. I miss her. '03 Acura RSX - Daily Driver ASE Master Tech & L1 Adv. Engine Perf. and Mechanical Engineer
Message # 4 18.03.23 - 11:14:08
RE: Video quality comparission

JonUK

user




Statistics:
Messages: 998
Registration: 06.30.2001

Re: interesting 

---------------------
Message # 5 18.03.23 - 11:19:46
RE: Video quality comparission

SDKCM3

user




Statistics:
Messages: 459
Registration: 06.12.2001

Yeah what he said. All in all, it's a pretty smart way to estimate quality without "quality measuring tools". which happen to also succomb to the same psycovisual deficiencies.

---------------------
Message # 6 18.03.23 - 11:24:27
RE: Video quality comparission
Better throttle : Previous topicNext topic: GK doesn't read length correctly anymore!
Pages:  1  

The administrator has prohibited guests from replying to messages! To register, follow the link: register


Participants